Floyd suggests a blockbuster: top Mets pitching prospect Jonah Tong plus Brett Baty and Ronny Mauricio for Brewers ace Freddy Peralta. Betting impact: acquiring Peralta would likely lower Mets’ run allowance and shift short-term moneylines toward New York, making under totals and pitching props on Mets starters more attractive for bettors.
Mets Trade Proposal: Cliff Floyd Eyes Brewers’ Freddy Peralta to Bolt Rotation
Cliff Floyd has publicly pitched a bold plan to upgrade the Mets’ rotation: trade for Milwaukee ace Freddy Peralta. Floyd argues the Mets’ next priority should be a proven starting pitcher in the MLB, and he outlined a package built around top pitching prospect Jonah Tong alongside major-league pieces such as Brett Baty and Ronny Mauricio.
Why the Mets Still Need Starting Pitching
New York has added arms to the bullpen this offseason, but the rotation remains a question mark beyond 32-year-old Kodai Senga. Senga struggled last year and briefly accepted a Triple-A assignment to work on his mechanics. With the rest of the staff lacking a clear No. 1, acquiring an established starter would provide immediate impact down the stretch.
Peralta: Proven Production, Short-Term Control
Freddy Peralta authored a 17-win season with a 2.70 ERA for last year’s best-record club and is a two-time All-Star. He’s entering the final year of his current contract, which makes him a realistic trade target for a team willing to pay now for rotation certainty. Peralta’s high-end stuff and recent consistency are the draw in Floyd’s proposal.
Proposed Package and Fit
The centerpiece would be 22-year-old Jonah Tong, a highly regarded right-handed pitching prospect who made five big-league starts last season. Tong struck out 22 batters in 18 2/3 innings but also suffered a 7.71 ERA over that small sample. Floyd suggested adding Brett Baty and Ronny Mauricio to sweeten the deal — players whose profiles could align with Milwaukee’s emphasis on controllable position players and upside.
Front-Office Considerations
The price for Peralta would be steep for a one-year rental unless New York pursued a contract extension. Mets payroll flexibility could allow them to extend an acquired ace, but that raises the long-term cost of surrendering top young talent. For Milwaukee, receiving controllable, cost-controlled position players and a pitching prospect fits a model that often values projectable internal pieces.
Betting and Market Implications
If the Mets were to land Peralta, expect immediate line movement: New York would become a stronger short-term betting favorite in many matchups, and game totals may tilt toward the under as the rotation’s quality improves. Bettors might target Mets starters’ ERA-based props and Peralta’s individual starts. Conversely, the trade would reduce the Mets’ prospect-driven upside in long-range futures markets, a factor bettors should weigh before placing season-long wagers.
What Bettors Should Watch Next
Monitor official transaction reports and sportsbooks for line shifts. Until a deal is confirmed, odds will remain speculative; confirmed acquisition of Peralta would likely produce rapid market reaction. Bettors should balance short-term game lines against the longer-term loss of high-upside prospects when evaluating futures or season-long investment.
Guardians' Travis Bazzana receives high praise from MLB prospect insider
A former MLB All-Star has a trade idea to upgrade the New York Mets starting rotation, but the price is steep.
Newsweek
