Chicago weighing a move for Alex Bregman would likely force roster shuffles — moving Matt Shaw to second and trading Nico Hoerner — which could tighten Cubs' offensive odds. Betting outcome: if Bregman signs, expect shorter moneyline odds and higher implied run totals for the Cubs; uncertainty around Hoerner could create value on Cubs futures until the roster is settled.
Cubs’ Bregman Pursuit Creates a Roster Puzzle
The Chicago Cubs have shown clear interest in free-agent third baseman Alex Bregman, but signing him would trigger tough decisions. Matt Shaw, a former top prospect and the club’s No. 13 pick in 2023, remains the projected everyday option at third. Shaw struggled for much of 2025, posting a .689 OPS, but he showed improvement at the plate and with his glove down the stretch.
Why Shaw’s Future Matters
Shaw is just 24 and the organization appears invested in giving him another chance in 2026. That age and pedigree make the Cubs hesitant to push him aside immediately, even if a proven veteran like Bregman is available. The front office must weigh long-term upside against the immediate impact Bregman would bring to the lineup.
Trade Options: Who Moves to Make Room?
One clear solution is a positional shift: move Shaw to second base and trade Nico Hoerner. Hoerner, entering his prime and a clubhouse leader, will be a free agent after next season and already attracts trade interest. Dealing him would open third base and middle-infield flexibility, but cost the Cubs a key veteran presence.
Market Dynamics Behind the Scenes
Insiders have suggested Bregman’s top suitors include Boston, Arizona and Toronto, along with Chicago. Some teams may need to make corresponding moves — for example, Arizona could consider moving a current infielder to balance payroll and roster fit. Representation and agent timelines could also influence when deals happen, potentially affecting offseason pacing.
Weighing the Gamble: Short-Term Gain vs. Long-Term Development
Trading Hoerner to get Bregman provides an immediate offensive upgrade but risks chemistry and future club control. Keeping Shaw at third signals patience and a developmental approach, but could leave the club without a proven middle-of-the-order bat. The Cubs’ decision will hinge on whether they prioritize a win-now acquisition or continued investment in young internal talent.
What to Watch Next
Monitor internal discussions about Shaw’s positional versatility, reports on trade interest in Hoerner, and any movement from teams linked to Bregman. Those signals will reveal whether the Cubs lean toward maintaining youth development or pivoting to a veteran-first approach that could reshape their offseason strategy.
Yankees expected to be in mix with Mets, Red Sox and more on elite right-hander on trade market
The Cubs might have to make a controversial decision if they want to sign Alex Bregman in free agency.
Si
