NHL agent poll: How should Connor McDavid approach his next contract?

Connor McDavid appears poised to favor a short-term deal to preserve free-agent leverage. Betting outcome: sportsbooks may price markets toward McDavid remaining unsigned through this season and testing unrestricted free agency next summer, boosting odds on him changing teams in 2026. Punters could back “no long-term extension” markets or wait for post-season clarity as the rising salary cap reshapes his market value and contender valuations.

Connor McDavid at a Contract Crossroads

Connor McDavid enters a contract year facing one of the most consequential decisions of his career. With generational talent, a Stanley Cup still eluding him and salary-cap dynamics shifting, McDavid must weigh short-term flexibility against the security of a long-term deal. Multiple unnamed agents offered perspectives on strategy, term, salary and legacy as the clock runs on a decision that will ripple across the NHL.

What Agents Advise

Take Time and Gather Data

Several agents urged patience. Their consensus: starting the season and assessing Edmonton’s championship trajectory, management plans and the market of emerging contenders provides the clearest picture. Advanced analytics and predictive modeling were recommended to move beyond gut instinct when weighing probability of sustained contention.

Short-Term vs. Long-Term

Many agents recommend short-term contracts (one to three years) to preserve flexibility and benefit from looming salary-cap increases that will raise top-player AAVs. A short-term deal could let McDavid re-enter the market while still in his prime, or put pressure on Oilers ownership to invest around him for immediate contention.

Salary Expectations

Agents who weighed in assume McDavid will demand maximum compensation relative to the next CBA limits. Several argued he has earned the leverage to wait and command top pay, potentially becoming the highest-paid player in the league. Others suggested a team-friendly compromise — sacrificing some salary for roster depth — could better position Edmonton to build a title contender.

Key Factors in the Decision

Winning Window

The likelihood of the Oilers assembling the supporting cast and goaltending needed to win multiple Cups is central. Agents pointed to dynasties’ structures: multiple stars and organizational commitment over years, not single-season gambits.

Cap Trajectory and Market Value

Rising salary caps increase the upside of short-term agreements. Agents noted that delaying a long-term commitment could yield substantially higher annual pay later, while also preserving team-choice flexibility for McDavid.

Legacy Considerations

The balance between legacy (winning championships) and financial maximization is recurring. Some compared McDavid to players who accepted team-friendly deals to build dynasties; others argued he’s already financially secure and should prioritize on-ice opportunity and control over his next move.

How This Moves Betting Markets

Immediate Market Response

Expect sportsbooks to open or shift markets toward McDavid not signing a long-term extension during this season and toward the probability he explores unrestricted free agency next summer. Futures markets on McDavid’s next team, as well as odds on Edmonton re-signing him before July 1, 2026, will likely see volatility as the season unfolds.

Smart Bet Strategies

- Consider value on “no long-term extension this season” or “McDavid to be UFA in 2026” early, while odds still reflect uncertainty. - Monitor lines for McDavid to change teams next offseason; those may shorten if Edmonton falters or if rival teams emerge as clear contenders. - Wait for post-trade-deadline and playoff performance data to reassess markets — injuries, cap moves and supporting-roster upgrades will shift probabilities.

Bottom Line

McDavid’s decision balances championship ambition, financial leverage and timing amid a rising salary cap. Agents largely favor short-term deals to preserve options, while some advocate a legacy-driven, team-friendly path to build a dynasty in Edmonton. For bettors, the clearest opportunity is to position for increased movement in markets tied to his contract status and team affiliation as the season clarifies contender landscapes and cap impacts.

The Athletic canvassed 10 agents to get their thoughts on what McDavid needs to consider about his NHL future.

Theathleticuk