Predicting the 2025-26 NHL season, from Stanley Cup contenders to bottom-feeders

Top betting angle: back established Cup contenders (Panthers, Knights, Oilers) in futures and expect value on middle-of-pack teams to outperform early-season lines; avoid longshot parlays with bottom-feeders. Early-season totals and short-series props could favor high-scoring contenders while punters should wait for roster clarity from muddled clubs like the Penguins before sizing up moneyline bets.

NHL Season Preview — Four-Division Breakdown

The NHL season looms, and forecasting remains a mix of analytics, roster moves and gut calls. This preview divides the league into four buckets: bottom-feeders rebuilding long-term, the bland middle-of-the-pack, legitimate Cup contenders, and a collection of teams where the projection is essentially a guess. Here’s a concise, journalist’s look at each group and what to watch for.

Bottom-Feeders: Rebuilds, Turnovers and Limited Upside

These teams are mostly projects. Some made the playoffs last year despite poor records; others are in clear rebuild mode. Expect frequent roster churn, young prospects to get heavy minutes, and seasons where wins are secondary to development.

Chicago Blackhawks and Connor Bedard

A team still clearly rebuilding around its top prospect. Management has traded assets and looks toward a longer-term plan rather than immediate contention. Expect more growing pains than surprise wins.

Buffalo Sabres

The organization still struggles to deliver consistent team performance despite flashes from individual stars. Some players could push for awards, but a full-team turnaround feels unlikely this season.

Pittsburgh Penguins

This franchise sits at a crossroads. Aging core questions and trade rumors could push Pittsburgh toward a purposeful drop in competitiveness or a desperate “win-now” tilt. Either way, expect volatility.

Philadelphia Flyers and Goaltending Concerns

A youth movement and offensive upside are countered by uncertain goaltending. Goalie performance will likely dictate how long the Flyers remain competitive in tight divisional races.

New York Islanders

A faux-.500 team with choices to make about the future. They’re closer to the playoff line than most bottom-feeders but likely not strong enough to be real threats without roster change.

Middle-of-the-Pack: Competitive, Uninspiring, and Bargain Targets

These teams occupy the mushy middle — good enough to be in the conversation but not necessarily true contenders. They’re often targets for sleepers and late-season value bets if injuries occur up top.

Calgary Flames

Solid goaltending prospects and a stable roster make them comfortable in the playoff mix, but they lack the upside to be feared as a Cup favorite.

Minnesota Wild and Kirill Kaprizov Distractions

After a big points season, questions remain about consistency. They’re closer to the top group than the bottom, but still short of a declaration as contenders.

Montreal Canadiens

Aggressive offseason moves suggest a tilt toward competing now. Additions and a rising young core make them a team to watch for a legitimate push back into the postseason.

Toronto Maple Leafs

A transition year after core changes. High expectations remain, but the regular season may be more about figuring out chemistry than delivering playoff success.

Cup Contenders: Powerhouses and Proven Winners

This group contains teams with high-end depth, elite talent, and championship expectations. They will be the primary targets for futures bettors and heavy action in playoff markets.

Florida Panthers

Back-to-back deep playoff runs and a championship pedigree make them a top futures pick, even with injuries to key pieces early. If healthy come spring, they’re a nightmare matchup.

Vegas Golden Knights

Consistently elite and adding premium talent keeps them squarely in the contender conversation. Expect them to challenge for the conference and Cup.

Edmonton Oilers and Connor McDavid

Despite lingering questions around goaltending and contracts, elite offense keeps Edmonton among the favorites to emerge from a deep conference.

Tampa Bay Lightning, Carolina Hurricanes, Boston Bruins

All franchises built to win now. Depth and playoff experience make them durable contenders; their postseason performance will come down to health and goaltending.

Your-Guess Division: High Variance and Unpredictable Outcomes

This collection includes teams with big upside and serious downside risk. Injuries, coaching changes, and inconsistent goaltending make season-long projections dicey.

Win-now Clubs with Salary Cap Constraints

Some teams enter the year with little cap space or aging cores; they can still make noise but are vulnerable to injuries and regression.

Young Teams Poised for Breakouts

One or two young clubs could surprise and leap into contention, especially if their early schedules are favorable and prospects take the next step.

Key Betting Takeaways

- Futures: Favor proven contenders for playoff depth and Cup runs; middle teams offer sleeper value if odds drift after a hot streak. - Matchups and Totals: Early-season totals favor high-scoring contenders; under/over props can be valuable before teams settle into systems. - Avoid heavy parlays with bottom-feeders until lineups and goaltending stabilize. Wait for clarity on teams with major trade rumors before committing large stakes.

Conclusion

Predicting an 82-game season is inherently risky. Expect surprises, swings in fortune, and late-season jockeying around cap, injuries and trades. For bettors and fans alike, the season will be defined less by preseason certainty and more by who navigates adversity and gets hot at the right time.

These aren't your typical divisions. Like every fall, let's split up the teams based on whether they're actually expected to be good or not.

Theathleticuk