Sonny Gray says he will reconsider his Cardinals future: 'I came here to win'

Sonny Gray finished the season with his 200th strikeout, but the Cardinals’ elimination raises the likelihood he’s traded this winter. Punters should monitor Gray trade-market props and Cardinals win-total lines—expect win-total and futures value to drift down for St. Louis while contenders’ pitching odds shorten if Gray lands on a playoff-ready club.

Sonny Gray’s Season Finale and Milestone

Sonny Gray closed his 2025 season with an 81-mph curveball that caught the upper outside corner for a called third strike against Heliot Ramos. Gray struck out seven in the game and finished the year with 200 strikeouts, marking back-to-back 200-K seasons and becoming just the fourth Cardinals pitcher since 1920 to accomplish that feat.

Cardinals Eliminated; Season Ends

The Cardinals’ 4-3 loss to the San Francisco Giants officially eliminated St. Louis from postseason contention for the third consecutive year. The defeat underscored organizational turbulence and set the stage for a consequential offseason.

Contract Status and Trade Possibilities

Gray signed a three-year, $75 million deal before the 2024 season and made all 32 starts this year, going 14-8 over 180 2/3 innings with a 4.28 ERA. The 2026 campaign is the final guaranteed year on his backloaded contract; he’s owed $35 million next season, with a $30 million club option for 2027. Those numbers make him both an attractive trade chip and a payroll headache for a club that trimmed spending this year.

Why a Trade Makes Sense

A rebuild under incoming president of baseball operations Chaim Bloom increases the likelihood the Cardinals explore moves to accelerate roster turnover. Proven starting pitching is in high demand around the league, and moving Gray would provide contenders with a near-ace addition while freeing payroll and assets for the rebuild. Gray controls much of his fate via a no-trade clause he declined to waive last winter, but his future in St. Louis now looks uncertain.

Gray’s Remarks on the Future

Gray said he has enjoyed his time with the club but came to St. Louis “to win” and signed with that expectation. He confirmed multiple conversations with Bloom and acknowledged he understands the organization’s direction, stopping short of committing to stay. With Gray’s contract structure and his stake in any move, offseason decisions will likely be driven by both competitive and financial factors.

Veteran Roster Decisions: Arenado and Contreras

Nolan Arenado retains a full no-trade clause but has indicated a willingness to expand his list of potential destinations. Willson Contreras’s season ended early with a biceps strain; he won’t need surgery and is expected to be healthy for spring training. Contreras switched to first base this year to add lineup flexibility and has two years and $36 million remaining on his deal. While he has expressed a preference to stay, financial considerations could push the Cardinals to explore trade options.

Offseason Timeline and Management

Expect the organization’s offseason framework and initial moves to become clearer once Bloom addresses the club after the regular season. Gray’s public comments—and the club’s broader roster posture—signal that significant changes could arrive quickly.

Implications for Bettors and Offseason Markets

Gray’s likely availability should shift several market angles: expect Cardinals season win-total lines to trend lower, Gray trade-market props to shorten for contenders, and starting-pitching futures for teams in the market to move in response to potential suitors. Bettors should monitor Gray-stay vs. traded prop markets, individual team odds if Gray is linked to a contender, and any immediate reaction to Bloom’s early offseason statements.

"I signed here two years ago with the expectation of winning and trying to win. That hasn't played out that way," the Cards ace said.

Theathleticuk