Antoine Semenyo’s goal for Man City was ruled out after a 5m40s VAR review for an Erling Haaland offside — part of a string of marathon checks (the longest recorded lasted eight minutes). Betting impact: avoid in-play “next goal” or very-late-goal markets at fixtures with a history of lengthy VAR reviews; favour pre-match result, Asian handicaps or wait for confirmed goal decisions before staking in-play.
VAR controversy overshadows Semenyo’s disallowed goal
Antoine Semenyo appeared to double Manchester City’s lead at St James’s Park, only for the strike to be chalked off after a 5 minutes 40 seconds VAR review that adjudged Erling Haaland offside. The delayed decision drew furious reaction from Pep Guardiola, left players and supporters baffled by the prolonged stoppage in sub-zero conditions, and reignited debate about whether VAR is increasingly acting as a re-referee rather than a clarifying tool.
The longest VAR checks in English football — ranked
5. Bournemouth vs Burnley (2023) — five minutes
A five-minute review in 2023 ruled Jay Rodriguez marginally offside after what looked like a crucial late equaliser. The decision changed the complexion of a relegation battle and left the visiting camp vocally unhappy.
4. West Ham vs Aston Villa (2024) — five minutes 37 seconds
Thomas Soucek had an equaliser disallowed after a 5m37s check that concluded the ball struck his arm. The lengthy delay at the London Stadium sparked complaints from fans and calls for clearer communication from officials.
3. Newcastle vs Man City (2026) — five minutes 40 seconds
The recent Semenyo incident ranks among the longest reviews. Haaland’s position on the line was the focus of the analysis, with the resulting overturn deciding a high-profile Cup tie and prompting managerial outrage.
2. West Ham vs Nottingham Forest (2025) — six minutes 14 seconds
A 6m14s stoppage investigated a flick-on by Nikola Milenkovic. The goal was ultimately awarded, but the prolonged pause drew fresh scrutiny over what constitutes sufficient cause for extended checks.
1. Bournemouth vs Wolves (2025) — eight minutes
The longest recorded VAR check ran to eight minutes in an FA Cup tie, examining a potential handball and offside involving Dean Huijsen. Supporters on both sides vented frustration, chanting that the stoppage had taken the spontaneity out of the match.
Why these delays matter
Long VAR checks disrupt game rhythm, chill stadium atmospheres and place referees under intense public pressure. Critics argue that marginal decisions should be handled quicker or with clearer thresholds to prevent VAR from becoming a game-stopping re-referee. Clubs and governing bodies face increasing calls to tighten protocols and improve the speed and transparency of communications to fans and broadcasters.
Practical takeaways for bettors and match-watchers
Long VAR reviews change the risk profile of in-play markets. Quick tips for punters: - Avoid betting on immediate in-play goal markets (next goal/next 10 minutes) at venues or fixtures known for lengthy VAR checks. - Consider pre-match bets (outcome, Asian handicaps) that aren’t vulnerable to late reversals. - If betting in-play, wait for the game to restart after goal celebrations are confirmed before placing stakes. - Monitor teams’ VAR histories and referee/central officiating trends when pricing risk for late-game goal markets.
Conclusion
The Semenyo disallowing is the latest high-profile example of VAR’s growing influence on English football. Until procedures speed up and transparency improves, managers will vent, fans will fume, and punters should adapt their strategies around the increased potential for delayed, match-altering decisions.
Why was Antoine Semenyo’s second goal ruled out in Carabao Cup clash with Newcastle?
After Man City all but secured their place in the Carabao Cup final, Antoine Semenyo's blistering start to life in Manchester should have been the topic being discussed by pundits..
Mail Online
