Tom Brady remains the GOAT, but with Super Bowl LX set as Patriots vs Seahawks and Patrick Mahomes facing a major knee rehab, punters may find value backing the Patriots or betting player props on Drake Maye to outperform expectations while Mahomes’ futures remain risky.
Top 10 Quarterbacks in NFL History — Ranking Ahead of Super Bowl LX
As the NFL world debates all-time greatness, this ranking weighs championships, influence, peak performance and longevity. Below is a journalist’s take on the top 10 QBs, their defining traits and career numbers — with an eye on how these legacies shape narratives heading into Super Bowl LX.
10. Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs)
Mahomes (age 30) has already reshaped the quarterback position with three Super Bowl titles and a mix of clutch comebacks and highlight plays. Despite a difficult 2025 season and significant knee rehab ahead, his Hall of Fame trajectory is set. Career stats: 35,939 passing yards, 267 passing touchdowns.
9. Roger Staubach (Dallas Cowboys)
A true pioneer, Staubach’s NFL resume was shortened by naval service but his leadership and big-game résumé made him synonymous with the Cowboys’ rise. Two-time Super Bowl champion and a defining face of his era. Stats (era-adjusted): 22,700 yards, 153 TDs.
8. Aaron Rodgers (Packers, Jets, Steelers)
Rodgers combined elite precision and longevity, earning four MVPs and numerous Pro Bowls. Late-career moves and a short Steelers stint raised questions about his final chapter, but his passing excellence remains undeniable. Career stats: 66,274 yards, 527 TDs.
7. Dan Marino (Miami Dolphins)
Marino’s arm changed expectations for passing volume and big-play potential. He piled up yards and touchdowns in an era when the run still dominated, but a Super Bowl title eluded him. Career stats: 61,361 yards, 420 TDs.
6. John Elway (Denver Broncos)
Elway blended arm talent and physicality, producing iconic playoff moments and back-to-back Super Bowl wins to close his career. A prototype dual-threat leader who delivered when it mattered. Career stats: 51,475 yards, 300 TDs.
5. Johnny Unitas (Colts, Chargers)
Unitas set the template for the modern passing game, dominating an earlier era with multiple championships and MVP honors. His influence on QB play persists across generations. Career stats: 40,239 yards, 290 TDs.
4. Brett Favre (Falcons, Packers, Jets, Vikings)
Favre’s gunslinger mentality and ironman durability pushed the NFL into a high-volume, highlight-driven age. Three MVPs and a long career of spectacular wins and memorable moments. Career stats: 71,838 yards, 508 TDs.
3. Peyton Manning (Colts, Broncos)
Manning modernized quarterback preparation, film study and offensive control, earning five MVPs and a pair of Super Bowl rings. He combined brains and precision to dominate two different franchises. Career stats: 71,940 yards, 539 TDs.
2. Joe Montana (49ers, Chiefs)
“Joe Cool” engineered the 49ers dynasty with surgical playoff performances and four Super Bowl rings. A clutch, methodical passer who excelled in the West Coast offense and postseason pressure. Career stats: 40,551 yards, 273 TDs.
1. Tom Brady (Patriots, Buccaneers)
Brady’s combination of longevity, record-setting production and championship success places him atop NFL history. Seven Super Bowl victories, sustained excellence into his 40s and a relentless competitive drive define the GOAT. Career stats: 89,214 yards, 649 TDs.
Super Bowl LX Outlook
Super Bowl LX pits a youthful Patriots offense led by Drake Maye against the Seahawks’ Sam Darnold in a matchup that reframes narratives about the current QB landscape. Meanwhile, Patrick Mahomes’ recovery timeline will dominate offseason conversation, altering expectations for the Chiefs and league-wide power balances.
Betting Implications and What Punters Should Watch
- Favored market value: With Mahomes’ health uncertain and a Patriots-Seahawks final, lines could offer value on the Patriots if Maye’s form is steady.
- Prop bets: Consider Maye passing yardage and touchdown props — a rookie QB in a big game can outperform or underdeliver, creating exploitable markets.
- Futures risk: Avoid committing large futures to Mahomes-dependent outcomes until medical updates clarify his return timeline.
- Matchup angles: Look at offensive line health, receiving corps availability, and coaching tendencies; single-game props and live bets may offer better risk-reward than long-term futures.
Key Takeaways for Fans and Bettors
The all-time QB debate is both statistical and narrative-driven. Brady’s supremacy remains intact, while Mahomes’ injury introduces short-term uncertainty that impacts markets. For punters, the immediate Super Bowl LX matchup and player props present clearer, actionable opportunities than long-shot futures tied to recovering stars.
The weird part of Drake Maye's injury and making sense of Patriots' QB concern for Super Bowl
Drake Maye could win the Super Bowl and still be two decades behind Tom Brady.Brady's first year in the playoffs was straight out of Hollywood and it
Talksport
